U.S. Supreme Court Overturns FTC Independence: Legal Basis of the EU-U.S. Data Privacy Framework Further Undermined

The U.S. Supreme Court ruled on June 29, 2026, in Trump v. Slaughter, by a 6–3 majority, that the statutory removal protections for commissioners of the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) violate the constitutional separation of powers. As a result, the FTC is no longer an independent agency but is subject to the authority of the U.S. President. Since the European Commission cites the FTC’s independence as a key prerequisite for its adequacy decision on the EU-U.S. Data Privacy Framework, questions about the framework’s continued viability arise once again. For companies in the DACH region that transfer personal data to the United States, this creates an additional need for review.
Background
The case arose from President Trump’s dismissal of FTC Commissioner Rebecca Slaughter in March 2025, even though none of the grounds specified in the FTC Act – inefficiency, neglect of duty, or malfeasance in office – applied. Slaughter sued for reinstatement, relying on the 1935 decision Humphrey’s Executor v. United States, in which the Supreme Court had expressly affirmed the FTC’s independence from presidential control. The Supreme Court has now reversed the lower court’s ruling and declared the statutory removal protections unconstitutional. The central rationale is the so-called “Unitary Executive Theory”: executive power is vested solely in the President, meaning that agencies performing executive functions must be subject to presidential control. This removes the previous distinction between independent regulatory agencies and the President’s authority to direct the FTC. The decision is also likely to have implications beyond the FTC for other U.S. agencies with comparable statutory protections for their independence.
Legal and Data Protection Assessment (EU/GDPR)
Under EU law, the independence of supervisory authorities responsible for the protection of personal data is not merely an administrative matter but is enshrined in primary law – in Article 16(2) TFEU and Article 8(3) of the Charter of Fundamental Rights of the European Union. Third countries must reflect this level of protection in order for the European Commission to determine that they provide an “adequate level of data protection.” In Implementing Decision (EU) 2023/1795 of 10 July 2023, which underpins the EU-U.S. Data Privacy Framework, the FTC is consistently described as an independent supervisory and enforcement authority. Following the Supreme Court’s ruling, however, this description no longer reflects the factual situation.

Accordingly, the organization noyb, led by Max Schrems, has already sent a letter to the European Commission calling for an orderly withdrawal of the adequacy decision and has announced legal action before the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU). Legally, however, the decision remains in force for the time being. In its Schrems II judgment, the CJEU clarified that an adequacy decision remains valid until it is repealed by the Commission or declared invalid by the CJEU. At the same time, Schrems II also establishes an obligation for national supervisory authorities to take such a ruling into account when assessing specific data transfers. Consequently, the implications are not limited to transfers based on the adequacy decision itself: companies relying on Standard Contractual Clauses (SCCs) or Binding Corporate Rules (BCRs) must also regularly consider the independence of U.S. supervisory and oversight bodies – such as the PCLOB or the Data Protection Review Court – as part of their Transfer Impact Assessments. This basis for assessment has also been significantly undermined by the Supreme Court’s ruling.
Risk Assessment for Organizations
For companies in the DACH region, the ruling does not mean that existing data transfers immediately become unlawful. However, it creates substantial legal uncertainty that must be documented and assessed as part of the accountability obligation under Article 5(2) GDPR. Companies that have so far relied solely on certification under the Data Privacy Framework should assume that this transfer mechanism has become vulnerable to legal challenge once again and may cease to apply – either through withdrawal by the European Commission itself or through a subsequent declaration of invalidity by the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU). Based on previous experience, such a decision is unlikely in the short term; noyb itself expects a decision to take two to three years. However, this should not be interpreted as an all-clear, but rather as a transitional period during which supervisory authorities are likely to scrutinize data transfers to the United States more closely. Companies that primarily rely on Standard Contractual Clauses (SCCs) or Binding Corporate Rules (BCRs) are also affected, as their Transfer Impact Assessments are based on the same assumptions regarding the independence of supervisory authorities that have now been called into question by the ruling. This is particularly relevant for companies that are highly dependent on U.S. hyperscalers for sensitive data processing, for example in the HR, healthcare, or financial sectors.
Recommendations for Action
As a first step, companies should take an inventory of their existing international data transfers and determine the legal basis on which each transfer actually relies – an adequacy decision, Standard Contractual Clauses (SCCs), or Binding Corporate Rules (BCRs). For transfers based on SCCs or BCRs, it is advisable to update the relevant Transfer Impact Assessments to reflect the latest ruling. At the same time, companies should monitor statements and guidance issued by the European Data Protection Board (EDPB) and national supervisory authorities in the coming weeks, as these are expected to provide indications of how the situation will be handled in practice. Regardless of the current developments, it is also advisable to conduct a general dependency analysis of U.S. cloud services and prepare potential alternatives or transition scenarios – not with a view to an immediate switch, but as a documented Plan B in case the legal situation changes at short notice.
Conclusion
The ruling itself does not yet directly change the legal framework for data transfers to the United States. However, it undermines a key premise of the EU-U.S. Data Privacy Framework and is likely to reignite the ongoing debate about digital dependencies on U.S. providers. For Data Protection Officers and company management, this is an opportunity to update their risk assessments for U.S. data transfers before a decision by the European Commission or the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) makes such action mandatory.

Wenn Sie die eigene Transferstruktur und die aktuelle Risikolage im Detail einordnen lassen möchten, stehen wir Ihnen gerne beratend zur Seite:
Sources
U.S. Supreme Court: Trump v. Slaughter, No. 25-332, decision of June 29, 2026

noyb.eu (29 June 2026): “US Supreme Court just blew up EU-US Data Transfers” noyb.eu

Commission Implementing Decision (EU) 2023/1795 of 10 July 2023 on the EU-U.S. Data Privacy Framework

Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU), judgment of 16 July 2020, C-311/18 (Schrems II)

Reuters (29 June 2026): “US Supreme Court backs Trump’s firing of FTC member”

More news

Technical Measures vs. AI Agents: Is a Data Protection Violation Inevitable?

2026 is once again a year of numerous simultaneous developments in data protection in Germany and across Europe: the highest GDPR fine ever imposed in Germany, another EU-wide coordinated enforcement action – this time focusing on transparency and information obligations – and key implementation phases of various EU digital laws, including the new transparency requirements

Read more…

Phishing via a legitimate Microsoft address: Power BI abuse and GDPR obligations for companies

Since January 2026, a sophisticated phishing campaign has been active in which attackers send deceptive emails using the legitimate Microsoft sender address no-reply-powerbi@microsoft.com . This is technically possible due to a legitimate feature of Microsoft Power BI: when creating a dashboard, any external email address can be added as a subscriber, and the content of the automatically sent notification can be freely configured.

Read more…